Home > What Coffee Would You Recommend?

Coffee Choices
Which Coffee Should I Choose?

If you like sweeter coffee or a caffeine punch, choose a lighter roast.
(Ethiopia, Kenya, or Guatemala make good choices -or- try Southwest Harbor Blend)

If you like a rich coffee flavor and aroma, with hints of background flavors, choose a medium or medium/dark roast.
(Costa Rica, Colombia, Nicaragua, Guatemala, and Brazil make good choices)

If you prefer a coffee with slightly more bite -or- you add sugar, cream, or flavorings to your coffee, choose a dark roast.
Sumatra and Nicaragua make good choices -or- try MainSail or Cadillac Mountain blends.)

Sort By:
Page of 1
Captain's Circle Captain's Circle

Being the Captain has its advantages.

With your Captain's Circle membership, you earn:
Free shipping*
"Captain Only" pricing discounts of 10-20 percent.
Early Access to new releases
Exclusive access to rare coffees
Automatic delivery options
Monthly deliveries of coffees, tips, recipes, and more!

Your membership starts with a "Welcome Aboard" package which includes:
A pour-over coffee brewer
Coffee samples
Tasting guide
Ship's Log

Our Price: $14.99/1 month(s)

Monthly Captain's Circle Membership